Your sourdough starter will experience many things. From extreme hunger to stability, it will literally make you want to pull your hair out. Fortunately, there are subtle ways to tell if your starter is doing well or not. If your sourdough starter smells like vinegar, or is starting to resemble that familiar acidic flavor and you're not sure if that's considered a good thing or a bad thing, then here's what to do!
Table of Contents
What should a sourdough starter smell like?
All in all, your sourdough starter should turn out great yeast smell. However, if it emits an unpleasant smell, then this may mean that your beginner is hungry.
The smell of vinegar is quite normal, as it is a byproduct of acetic acid. The good bacteria in the sourdough starter tend to gobble up the nutrients in the flour, which means it's time to feed the starter once more.
If you've noticed a recurring sour smell, you can increase the amount of food you feed your starter.
What should a sourdough starter look like?
A healthy and determined sourdough starter should look nice and bubbles after it has been fed. It should have the consistency of thick pancake batter. It will come out of its container without spilling easily.
My sourdough starter smells like vinegar
If yours The sourdough starter smells of alcohol, vinegar or nail polish remover, means it is absolutely starved and has produced kits of acetic acid. This means that the lactic acid bacteria have devoured the good nutrients in the flour and need to be fed.
If your starter smells really sour, try increasing the number of feeds. If you feed him once a day, try feeding him twice a day.
You can also try switching to a different type of flour so that the bacteria can digest the nutrients at a slower rate. You can use whole grain flour or all purpose flour.
My sourdough starter is very sour
To avoid extreme sour notes, be sure to feed your starter with all-purpose flour. This allows your starter some time to eat through the nutrients, meaning you won't have to feed your starter as often.
Make sure the sourdough starter doesn't ferment too long before using it I bake bread with dough.
My sourdough starter is not sour enough
You may have a starter that is not sour enough, and this usually happens when the engine is not running, or quite mature to use it yet.
How to fix a starter that smells like vinegar?
Here's how to fix a starter that smells like vinegar:
- Get your sourdough starter that is 100% hydrated.
- In a clean jar, put a small initial amount of sourdough.
- Then double the amount to feed the sourdough starter.
- Pour water into the mixture
- Mix the mixture well, then cover and let it stand at room temperature.
- Repeat this 3-4 times and you should notice a difference in the smell of the starter.
Both yeast and bacteria are present in the beginning of your sourdough. Yeast produces ethanol or alcohol and carbon dioxide.
How do I know if my starter has gone bad?
A slight vinegar smell should not be a cause for concern. However, you should keep a close eye on your starter.
If your starter smells like vomit, hard cheese or dirty socks, then it should be thrown out immediately. Don't worry too much about the vinegar smell, as this is probably the work of lactic acid bacteria.
Other signs of your dough starting to deteriorate are: mold growth AND colorful shades pink, blue or orange.
Furthermore, if you don't feed the starter regularly, it won't last long. You can test whether your starter is alive or not by feeding it several times a day.
Vinegar with the initial smell of sourdough
As long as your sourdough starter doesn't smell like socks, vomit, or show signs of mold, you should be good to go!
Sourdough starter FAQ smells like vinegar
How do you know if your sourdough starter is spoiled?
If your sourdough starter is spoiled, it will show visible signs of mold or an orange/pink tint.
How do you make sourdough starter less vinegary?
Your starter may be hungry, so try doubling the amount of sourdough starter, you can also add some honey to your batter.
What should sourdough starter smell like?
When your starter is in good shape, it should smell fresh, fruity and yeasty.
Is my sourdough starter supposed to smell sour?
No. Often a hungry sourdough starter gives off a sour smell, but this is quite normal and only takes a little time to revive it.
